Explained 101: Mutual Fund Overlap

Rahul Verma
August 12, 2023
mutual fund overlap
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on whatsapp
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on whatsapp

Investing in mutual funds is a popular way for individuals to participate in the stock market while mitigating risks through diversification. However, a concept that often goes overlooked is “mutual fund overlap.” This refers to the situation where different mutual funds in a portfolio hold similar or even identical securities, potentially leading to unintended concentration and diminished diversification benefits. In this blog, we will delve into the world of mutual fund overlap, understand its implications, identify the causes, and explore strategies to manage and optimize your investment portfolio.

Understanding the Labyrinth of Mutual Fund Overlap:

The essence of mutual fund overlap materializes when two or more funds partake in a substantial confluence of holdings. This phenomenon is orchestrated by a myriad of factors, encompassing fund managers navigating analogous investment strategies, traversing parallel trajectories in targeting specific market sectors, or even capitalizing on the allure of universally favoured stocks. While a certain degree of overlap is inevitably woven into the fabric of portfolio construction, the undue proliferation of this phenomenon can undermine the bedrock of diversification—an indispensable cornerstone of effective risk management.

The Ripple Effect of Mutual Fund Overlap:

  • Diversification Diminished: The main worry with mutual fund overlap is that it chips away at the effectiveness of diversification. Owning funds that have too much in common could mean facing higher risks when the market takes a dip, as potential losses could be concentrated in just a few overlapping stocks.
  • Double the Trouble: When funds overlap, there’s a chance you might end up unknowingly owning too much of certain stocks or sectors. While it’s okay to have some level of focus, having too much exposure can amplify your losses if those specific stocks or sectors perform poorly.
  • Paying Twice: Investing in multiple funds that share significant overlap could mean paying fees and expenses multiple times over. This eats into potential returns and might not be the best strategy.

Why Does Mutual Fund Overlap Happen?

  • Following the Trends: Sometimes, particular sectors or industries become the “in thing” in the market. This leads different fund managers to all invest in the same stocks, creating overlap.
  • Chasing the Benchmark: Many funds aim to track a specific benchmark index. This can naturally lead to holding similar stocks, mainly if multiple funds track the same index.
  • Safety in Numbers (or Not): To not fall behind their peers, fund managers might invest in popular stocks, which ultimately adds to the overlap.

Strategies to Untangle Mutual Fund Overlap:

  • Know Your Portfolio: Regularly assess your collection of funds to spot overlapping holdings. You can use online tools or even consult a financial advisor to get a clear picture.
  • Define Your Goals: Lay out what you want from your investments and how much risk you’re willing to handle. This helps you choose funds that match your goals and avoid accidental overlap.
  • View the Bigger Picture: Instead of evaluating funds in isolation, look at your entire portfolio. Ensure your combined holdings provide diversification across various types of investments and sectors.
  • Explore Fresh Options: Do your research and consider different funds that can complement your existing holdings while reducing overlap. Look for funds that follow distinct strategies or have unique styles. We discussed lesser-known funds in detail in our blog earlier, read here.
  • Streamline Your Holdings: If you discover substantial overlap, think about consolidating your funds. Sell redundant ones and reinvest the proceeds into more diversified options.

In Conclusion:

Mutual fund overlap is a crucial aspect of portfolio management that often doesn’t get the attention it deserves. By understanding why it happens, its impacts, and how to address it, you can craft a more robust and well-rounded investment portfolio. Taking a proactive approach to managing mutual fund overlap can boost your chances of consistent returns while keeping unwarranted risks at bay. Consult a mutual fund advisor for in detailed analysis of your portfolio. 

Remember, a balanced portfolio is your ticket to long-term financial success.

FAQs About Mutual Fund Overlap

Q1: What is mutual fund overlap?

Mutual fund overlap refers to the situation where different mutual funds within an investment portfolio share similar or even identical holdings, particularly stocks. This can lead to unintentional concentration in specific securities or sectors, potentially impacting diversification.

Q2: Why is mutual fund overlap a concern?

Excessive mutual fund overlap can reduce the benefits of diversification. If multiple funds hold the same stocks, losses could be concentrated in those stocks during market downturns, increasing overall portfolio risk. It might also result in double exposure to certain sectors, and investors could end up paying duplicate fees for similar holdings.

Q3: What causes mutual fund overlap?

Mutual fund overlap can occur due to various factors, including fund managers following similar investment strategies, tracking the same benchmark index, or investing in popular stocks. Market trends and a herd mentality among fund managers can also contribute to overlap.

Q4: How can I manage mutual fund overlap in my portfolio?

To manage mutual fund overlap, consider these steps:

  • Regularly review your portfolio to identify overlapping holdings.
  • Clearly define your investment goals and risk tolerance to guide fund selection.
  • Evaluate your entire portfolio’s asset allocation for adequate diversification.
  • Research and explore alternative funds that complement existing holdings.
  • Consolidate holdings by selling redundant funds and reallocating into more diversified options if necessary.

Q5: Is some level of mutual fund overlap acceptable?

 Yes, some overlap is natural and unavoidable, especially when funds track similar indexes or market segments. A certain level of overlap might even be intentional, based on your investment strategy. The key is to strike a balance that aligns with your diversification goals and risk tolerance while avoiding excessive concentration in a few holdings.


Risk Assessment Test